How to Evaluate and Select the Right ERP Software for Your Organization

Posted by Roy Semple on

Selecting the right Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software for your organization is like setting the foundation for a skyscraper—it's a critical choice that will support all of your business operations, so it needs to be done methodically. Here's a simple 10-step approach to clarify your requirements and arrive at an ERP selection decision that meets the needs of your organization. 

With the right ERP software, an organization can improve its efficiency, data accuracy, and decision-making processes. However, with so many options on the market, it's easy to get side-tracked and end up making the wrong choice. Read on for a structured approach to evaluating and selecting the best ERP software for your business.

1. Define Your Business Requirements

Before diving into the sea of available ERP options, the first step is to understand and document your business needs. An ERP should align with your organization’s processes, goals, and growth plans. Establish a cross-functional team that represents all parts of your business to ensure all requirements are captured. This includes considering factors like:

- The size and geography of your business
- Industry-specific needs
- Compliance and reporting requirements
- Integration with existing systems
- User-friendliness and training needs
- Scalability for future growth

ERP Software Requirements Template
2. Set Your Budget

Understanding the total cost of ownership is crucial. This is not just the initial purchase price, but also ongoing costs like maintenance, upgrades, additional licenses, and training. Remember to consider both direct and indirect costs when setting your budget. It’s important to be realistic about what you can afford while considering the return on investment that a well-chosen ERP system can bring.

3. Identify Potential ERP Solutions

With a clear picture of what you need and what you can afford, you can start identifying ERP systems that fit those criteria. Create a long list of potential ERP solutions, and then whittle it down to a shortlist. Look for systems that have a proven track record in your industry and are known for robustness and scalability.

4. Evaluate the ERP Vendors

The ERP software is only as good as the vendor behind it. You want a vendor with not just a solid ERP offering, but also a strong support and implementation track record. Consider:

- Vendor reputation and stability
- Quality of customer support
- Community or ecosystem
- Post-implementation services
- Their roadmap for the future

5. Conduct a Thorough Software Evaluation

Once you’ve selected a few potential ERP systems, evaluate them against your documented requirements. Use a weighted scoring system to assess how well each system meets each requirement. According to SelectHub, common evaluation criteria include functionality, usability, technology, and costs. The ERP that scores the highest across all categories should be a leading contender.

During this phase, it’s also important to request demonstrations and potentially a proof of concept. Seeing the ERP in action and having your end-users interact with it can reveal insights that aren't apparent in vendor documentation.

6. Check References and Case Studies

An ERP might look perfect on paper, but the real-world application can tell a different story. Speak to references provided by the ERP vendors to understand their experiences. Look for case studies or testimonials from companies similar in size and industry to yours. This can give you a better understanding of the implementation process, the challenges faced, and the benefits realized.

7. Decide on Deployment Options

Modern ERP systems offer various deployment options, such as on-premises, cloud-based (SaaS), or a hybrid approach. Each has its advantages and disadvantages. For example, cloud-based solutions may offer cost savings and easier upgrades, while on-premises solutions might give you more control over the data and system.

8. Plan for the Future

Technology and business needs are constantly evolving, and your chosen ERP should be able to adapt to future changes. Ensure that the ERP system you select is built on modern technology that can accommodate new processes, integrations, and data analytics needs that may arise as your business grows.

9. Review and Decide

Gather all your research, scores, feedback from demos, and reference checks, and then review the findings with your selection team. Discuss any concerns and make sure there is a consensus on the chosen ERP. The decision should be unanimous because the success of an ERP implementation relies heavily on organization-wide acceptance and support.

10. Negotiate and Implement

Finally, after selecting the right ERP, enter into negotiations with the vendor. This is where you can clarify the final costs, support details, and any customization or implementation services needed. Once the contract is signed, it’s time to plan the implementation phase meticulously, ensuring minimal disruption to your business operations.

These 10 steps provide you with a practical roadmap to evaluate and select an ERP solution that aligns with your organization’s needs and is adaptable for future growth and changes.

Lean Software Selection Steps

For a more detailed understanding of enterprise software evaluation, vendor comparison scoring, and POCs or ERP demos, see this article on SelectHub's Lean Selection Methodology


Share this post